Interpreting the Effect of Embellishments on Chart Visualizations : Appendice

Tiffany Andry, Christophe Hurter, Francois Lambotte, Pierre Fastrez and Alexandru Telea

Abstract Infographics range from minimalism that aims to convey the raw data to elaborately decorated, or embellished, graphics that aim to engage readers by telling a story. Several studies have shown evidence to the negative, but also positive, effects on embellishments. We conducted a set of experiments to gauge more precisely how embellishments affect how people relate to infographics and make sense of the conveyed story. By analyzing questionnaires, interviews, and eye-tracking data simplified by trail bundling, we show that, within certain bounds, embellishments have a positive effect on how users get engaged in understanding an infographic, with very limited downside. To our knowledge, our work is the first that fuses the aforementioned three information sources to understand infographics. Our findings can help to design more fine-grained studies to quantify the effects of embellishments and also to design infographics which effectively use the positive aspects identified for embellishments.




Image details: In the following we show 19 visualizations. For each visualization, we show 6 images from left to right and top to bottom: embelished visualization, embelished visualization with gaze recording, embelished visualization with gaze simplification, standardized visualization, standardized visualization with gaze recording, standardized visualization with gaze simplification.



1) Fashionable and cheap travel destinations September to December


2) Number of sleep hours on New Year's night in different countries


3) Life span of different animal species


4) Total food consumed in 2010 per food type in a meal


5) Condom usage in a first encounter in Europe


6) Population percentage having a pet in different countries


7) Top worldwide importers of champagne


8) Most popular touristic places on Instagram


9) Wine-accompagnied meals breakdown per time of day and age


10) Multiculturality evolution, Bovisa district, Milan, 1999-2011


11) Most murderous seasons of Game of Thrones (deaths/season)


12) Laser saber counts per color in Star Wars


13) Price of McDonald's products, 1950 vs 2014


14) Frozen producs per product type in US, 1974-2014


15) Most generous world countries (donations)


16) Movie watching comparison, Arab countries


17) World sales of French Beaujolais wine


18) Male vs female university professor counts in Spanish universities


19) Types of animals found beheaded in NY parks, 2004-2014